Critics Clash Over Johnny Depp in Ti West’s Dickens Adaptation ‘Ebenezer’
Film reviewers are offering mixed verdicts on director Ti West's holiday adaptation 'Ebenezer,' which casts Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge. While several commentators dismissed the star's prosthetic-heavy showing, others noted flashes of charm alongside widespread acclaim for an ensemble that features Tramell Tillman.

Film critics have offered sharply conflicting assessments of director Ti West's new holiday feature 'Ebenezer,' an adaptation of Charles Dickens' classic novella 'A Christmas Carol' anchored by Johnny Depp in the titular role. According to a review roundup published by The Hollywood Reporter, the release stands at a 51 percent approval score on Rotten Tomatoes as commentators grapple with the star's return to high-profile studio filmmaking.
The gothic adaptation leans into horror elements, framing Scrooge's late-night reckoning through heavy prosthetics and theatrical flair. The Hollywood Reporter noted that while the project does not necessarily break fresh ground, it functions effectively as a showcase restoring Depp to marquee status, likening his broad delivery to Albert Finney's performance in the 1970 musical adaptation 'Scrooge.'
Other critics took a substantially harsher stance against Depp's central casting. A review in the Boston Globe described the portrayal as hollow and unconvincing, declaring it the worst version of Scrooge on record and asserting that the performance lacked recognizable humanity. In a similar vein, IndieWire observed that Depp's performance relied on mannerisms that distracted from the narrative, though it praised the production whenever focus shifted to the surrounding cast.
Writing for Vulture, a reviewer pointed out that Depp's approach felt disconnected from the rest of the film, even while describing West's eerie interpretation of the holiday ghosts as visually inventive, notably highlighting Andrea Riseborough's chilling portrayal of the Ghost of Christmas Past. The New York Times framed the film as an exercise in nostalgia, questioning whether the performance serves as a creative breakthrough or merely a familiar replay of the star's past screen personas.
Conversely, several outlets found merit in the effort. The Guardian praised Depp's comedic timing and petulance, stating he excelled particularly during the early, unrepentant stages of the miser's journey. The Times UK observed that the narrative presents Depp as an actor capable of redemption, even while arguing the surrounding movie struggled to outshine previous cinematic versions of the story. The Daily Beast likewise characterized the film as a sturdy seasonal retelling that maintains enough chilling atmosphere to engage audiences.
Across multiple reviews, critics consistently highlighted the supporting ensemble as a bright spot in West's dark vision. Cast members including Tramell Tillman, Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint, Daisy Ridley, and Riseborough received broad recognition for grounding the story. 'Ebenezer' arrives in theaters this Friday.
